Thursday May 7, 2015 Search
Weather | Athens
14o C
09o C
News
Business
Comment
Life
Sports
Community
Survival Guide
Greek Edition
Double standards of EU and IMF

 Greece’s creditors imposed tax hikes while praising Latvia for focusing on spending cuts

By Dimitris Kontogiannis

High-level European Union and International Monetary Fund officials have called on Greece and other eurozone periphery countries facing a debt crisis to follow the example of Latvia in dealing with their economic problems. They are the same officials who have approved tax hikes and focused on tax revenues to close the Greek budget gap, running counter to Latvia’s deep budget spending cuts. The lesson from Latvia for both Greece and its creditors is that upfront spending cuts and a downsized public sector are key to a successful adjustment program.

Amid growing criticism for prescribing excessive austerity in the bailout programs imposed on eurozone periphery countries, the EU and the IMF have turned to Latvia in their search for a successful model. Their purpose is to show that internal devaluation policies can work in countries where currency devaluation is not an option.

Speaking to an IMF conference in Latvia’s capital Riga earlier this month, the fund’s head, Christine Lagarde, praised the small Baltic state, which sought international help at the end of 2008, for biting the bullet and tackling its economic problems fast and hard by taking some brave decisions. She also had warm words for Latvian politicians for internalizing the reform program.

It is true the Greek Socialist government under George Papandreou, which sought a bailout in May 2010, did not really endorse structural reforms. After a strong start in the summer of 2010 with the overhaul of the social security system, the administration’s priority seemed to be to protect the interests of its main voter base, namely the employees in the public sector, and meet the budget deficit target set out in the economic adjustment program.

The Socialist government tried to reconcile both goals by relying on tax hikes to reduce the budget deficit and limit expenditure cuts to minimize the impact on civil servants. As a result Greek civil servants avoided the tough luck of their Latvian colleagues, who saw almost 30 percent of their peers being laid off at the start of the program.

Moreover, the remaining employees experienced wage cuts of 26 percent on average compared to similar progressive cuts in Greece. Accustomed to job tenure and sensing the extent of the economic calamity, it is understandable that the vast majority of Greek civil servants have flocked to the Coalition of the Radical Left (SYRIZA) on promises it will not fire anyone in the civil service and will even swell its ranks with new hires.

In contrast to Latvia, the Greek tax raid spread the pain of fiscal consolidation to the whole economy from the beginning, mostly hurting the private sector. The latter had also to endure continued delays in payments to suppliers and others as the government chose to fully pay wages and pensions at the expense of building arrears to the private sector in excess of 6 billion euros. This technically decreased government spending as well.

Numbers do not lie. The tax revenues of the Greek general government went up to about 41 percent of GDP in 2011 from 38.2 percent in 2009 and are projected to rise further to 42.4 percent this year despite the longest and deepest recession in decades.

On the other hand, total spending has stabilized around 50 percent of GDP from an all-time high of 53.8 percent in 2009. This is way above the average of 45-46 percent during the 2001-08 period.

In Latvia, the general government spent 44.5 percent of output in 2009 but this figure declined to 39 percent in 2011 and is projected to fall to 38 percent in 2012. Tax revenues increased from 34.5 percent in 2009 to 35.6 percent in 2011, when the Latvian economy returned to growth, and is seen rising to 36 percent in 2012.

Nevertheless, despite all the praise for Latvia by EU and IMF officials, Greece’s fiscal consolidation has been bigger than the small Baltic country’s. The Greek primary budget deficit, which does not take into account interest payments on public debt, fell to 2.2 percent of GDP last year from 10.4 percent in 2009, an improvement of 8.2 percentage points. Latvia’s primary budget deficit fell to 2 percent of GDP in 2011 from 8.3 percent in 2009, a decrease of 6.3 percentage points in terms of output.

The improvement in the overall general government budget deficit has been similar in both countries, or 6.5 to 6.3 percentage points, but this is explained by their huge public debt burdens.

Of course, the Greek unemployment rate continues to climb, approaching 22 percent in March as the economy continues to weaken, while Latvia’s jobless rate appears to be heading south as its economy recovers, although it remains high above 15 percent.

All in all, the figures show Greece’s fiscal consolidation has been greater than Latvia’s so far. However, Greece’s heavy reliance on taxes to close the huge budget gap along with the former Socialist government’s half-hearted endorsement of structural reforms have undermined the private sector, dragging out the downturn and resulting in reform fatigue.

Although the country’s creditors cannot be blamed for the slow pace of structural reforms here, it is fair to say they are also accountable for stressing tax revenues as a means of filling the budget gap. It is therefore paradoxical to praise Latvia, which focused on spending cuts, as a success story while doing quite the opposite in Greece by approving tax raids. Unless they mistakenly believe it would have sufficed for the Greek economy to grow if local politicians and bureaucrats implemented reforms which usually bear fruit in the medium to long term with the public debt-to-GDP ratio above 150 percent.

ekathimerini.com , Sunday June 10, 2012 (23:02)  
Minimum wage is not enough
Gov’t awaits US alternative gas proposal
Luxury tax hike may fetch nothing
PM concession keeps ELA alive
SYRIZA to start mulling position on possible deal
SYRIZA’s political secretariat is due to meet on Friday as the party begins deliberating the concessions set to be made by the Greek government to its lenders. The meeting will take place am...
Prosecutor wants to see 40 defendants take the stand in Postbank loan trial
A prosecutor on Wednesday recommended that 40 people stand trial in connection to the alleged unsecured loans scandal at Hellenic Postbank (TT). Prosecutor Maria Soukara-Katsikadi said she f...
Inside News
SOCCER
UEFA concern over Greek soccer violence bill
Greece provoked fresh concern from European soccer's governing body UEFA on Wednesday over governmental interference which could lead to the Euro 2004 winners' international suspension. UEFA...
SOCCER
Greece set to escape ban as sports law goes to parliament
Greek soccer is set to breathe a sigh of relief as the country's controversial new sports law was submitted to parliament on Wednesday with the necessary amendments to avoid a FIFA and UEFA ...
Inside Sports
COMMENTARY
Greece´s ´Blazing Saddles´ strategy isn´t working
There's a scene in the 1974 Mel Brooks movie "Blazing Saddles" where the besieged sheriff points a gun at his own head and threatens to shoot himself if the townspeople threatening to kill h...
COMMENTARY
A ‘logical’ scenario vs historical accidents
The country has reached a point where there is only one “logical” scenario left. By now, Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras understands very well the meaning of bankruptcy, a credit event and a G...
Inside Comment
SPONSORED LINK: FinanzNachrichten.de
SPONSORED LINK: BestPrice.gr
 RECENT NEWS
1. Minimum wage is not enough
2. Gov’t awaits US alternative gas proposal
3. Luxury tax hike may fetch nothing
4. PM concession keeps ELA alive
5. Greek hotel rates return to pre-crisis levels
6. SYRIZA to start mulling position on possible deal
more news
Today
This Week
1. A ‘logical’ scenario vs historical accidents
2. Greece's 'Blazing Saddles' strategy isn't working
3. Greece said to have made 200 mln euro IMF payment due Wednesday
4. Mardas denies report he transferred cash abroad after joining gov't
5. Defense minister offers to bolster NATO, help fight against terrorism
6. Inexplicable decision
Today
This Week
1. Greece’s decade-long relationship with Merkel
2. Greek decision to exit euro would be disastrous for Greece
3. No need to widen the rift
4. Varoufakis attacked by anarchists while dining in Athens
5. Empty admissions of fault
6. Majority sees Greece headed for euro exit in Bloomberg user poll
   Find us ...
  ... on
Twitter
     ... on Facebook   
About us  |  Subscriptions  |  Advertising  |  Contact us  |  Athens Plus  |  RSS  |   
Copyright © 2015, H KAΘHMEPINH All Rights Reserved.