Monday December 22, 2014 Search
Weather | Athens
17o C
10o C
News
Business
Comment
Life
Sports
Community
Survival Guide
Greek Edition
Time approaching for the IMF to go

 Signs point to an exit of the Fund from the Greek program, but someone else must cover the resulting gap

By Dimitris Kontogiannis

The Greek economy has made its first step towards stabilization and recovery by registering a smaller-than-expected contraction last year. Whether this will lead to a gradual return to normalcy depends largely on political developments and market perceptions about the effectiveness of expected debt relief measures to be decided by the EU authorities. But the IMF and the EU clearly disagree on the best way to make Greece’s debt sustainable. One way to resolve this issue will be for the IMF to exit the Greek program in the second half of 2014. Some think market participants will rejoice, pushing Greek bond yields lower and helping the country fill the funding slack via a precautionary credit line from the ESM.

The role of the chief auditors of the EU, the IMF and the ECB, the so-called troika, in the eurozone debt crisis has come under scrutiny and has been criticized by members of the European Parliament in recent weeks – a bit too late, some may say, since Ireland exited the rescue program at the end of 2013 and Portugal is likely to do the same a few months from now. But this development is important for Greece, which is still struggling to meet high fiscal targets and to implement a host of structural reforms under its program. Also, an increasing number of Greek officials appear happy to point out the overly optimistic targets set in the first Greek bailout program back in May 2010 and the troika’s complete change of heart, which led to pessimistic estimates accompanied by proposed policy measures last year.

Even Finance Minister Yannis Stournaras, widely regarded as a technocrat who is on good terms with the troika, has criticized it in public, saying that the government would have done great damage to the economy if it had accepted the troika’s policy proposals last September to take additional austerity measures to close the estimated fiscal gap in 2014. Stournaras’s criticism may reflect exasperation with some policy demands deemed counterproductive and politically insensitive.

While criticism of the troika is mounting both in the EU and Greece, the time is approaching for the Eurogroup to give the green light for much-discussed debt relief measures. Athens appears confident revenues will exceed expenditures excluding interest payments on public debt to meet one of the prior actions, but the ongoing review of the adjustment program has yet to be concluded. It is reasonable to expect both sides to reach some kind of an agreement in the next month or so to open the road for loan disbursements ahead of the May expirations, amounting to more than 8 billion euros.

Still, the return of the Greek economy to growth for the first time since 2008 remains the most important challenge with the prospect of political uncertainty hovering and the debt overhang looming. History suggests that huge debt can undermine GDP growth and may destabilize a country. The Greek debt-to-GDP ratio is huge by any means and is seen exceeding 170 percent of GDP in 2013, standing at more than 315 billion euros. This debt overhang can have detrimental effects on growth via various channels.

It is well known that Germany and others in the EU disagree with the IMF’s proposal for a Greek debt write-off to make it sustainable and opt instead for interest rates cuts and a 20-year maturity extension of the bilateral loans. But the EU‘s preferred type of OSI (Official Sector Involvement) would have little impact on the debt-to-GDP targets in 2020 and 2022 set out in the DSA (Debt Sustainability Analysis) of the IMF, although it reduces the net present value (NPV) of the Greek debt according to analysts. But the EU and some analysts question the usefulness of DSA. They say it is a theoretical construct based on assumptions about variables such as GDP growth, interest rates and primary budget surpluses well into the future, and that even a small change in one of the variables can lead to large changes in the debt-to-GDP ratio.

This is more so in the Greek case since the biggest chunk of the debt, i.e. more than 240 billion euros, will be held by eurozone countries and institutions which have no interest in bankrupting the country and undermining the euro project – especially after Greece’s unprecedented fiscal effort and the almost certain delivery of a primary surplus in 2013 as well as the implementation of more than 80 percent of required structural reforms by the end of March or so. In this regard, the DSA of the Greek debt may have to be given up but the IMF is unlikely to accept this since it funds countries with sustainable debt based on its own method and calculations.

Given this fundamental disagreement between the EU and the IMF, the Greek government’s reported increasing malaise with the policy proposals of the IMF auditors and the objections of some emerging market countries to the IMF’s funding of Greece, the time may come for the IMF to leave the Greek program. Of course, this means somebody else will have to cover the resulting gap since IMF financing to Greece is projected to end in the first quarter of 2016. This could be Greece itself if the EU decides to back it by offering a precautionary credit line via the ESM. This would come on top of the projected financing gap of 11-15 billion euros for the 2014-2016 period which largely stems from the Greek debt buyback at end-2012 demanded by the EU and the IMF. Is it possible? Time will tell but some traders are willing to bet that markets will celebrate the IMF’s departure, pulling Greek yields down.

ekathimerini.com , Sunday February 16, 2014 (21:32)  
Political saga is harming liquidity
Bad timing for tenders as oil rates decline
Tax exemptions deprive state budget of over 3.5 bln euros
Teiresias to track letters of guarantee
Greek PM offers compromise solution with elections by end-2015
Prime Minister Antonis Samaras on Sunday presented a compromise solution to end a political stalemate that looks likely to send Greece to early general elections in about a month's time. Spe...
Environment Ministry to reconsider controversial bill
The government over the weekend appeared to backpedal on proposed amendments widely seen as compromising legislation protecting Greek forests as well as Plaka, Athens’s old quarter. The bill...
Inside News
SOCCER
Special day for Abidal, lucky one for PAOK
PAOK scraped through its Livadia challenge beating Levadiakos to remain on top of the Super League for Christmas, one point ahead of Olympiakos that enjoyed a great game at Kalloni and offer...
BASKETBALL
Explosive Barca unfazed by Panathinaikos, bomb scare
Panathinaikos lost 80-67 at home to Barcelona on Friday in a rather meaningless game at the end of the first group stage of the Euroleague, but the encounter will be remembered for the bomb ...
Inside Sports
INTERVIEW
‘Crisis of confidence will come back again and again,’ says Thomas Piketty
He’s treated like a rock star wherever he goes to lecture. His book “Capital in the 21st Century,” a study on income and wealth inequality from the 18th century to the present, recently tran...
COMMENTARY
Who lost Greece
If Greece collapses much will be said about where the fault lies. Sure, we all know the failings of Greek politicians. That said, much of the blame lies with outsiders who pushed Greece beyo...
Inside Comment
SPONSORED LINK: FinanzNachrichten.de
SPONSORED LINK: BestPrice.gr
 RECENT NEWS
1. Special day for Abidal, lucky one for PAOK
2. Political saga is harming liquidity
3. Bad timing for tenders as oil rates decline
4. Tax exemptions deprive state budget of over 3.5 bln euros
5. Teiresias to track letters of guarantee
6. Agenda
more news
Today
This Week
1. Greek PM offers compromise solution with elections by end-2015
2. Who lost Greece
3. ‘Crisis of confidence will come back again and again,’ says Thomas Piketty
4. Snubbing the moderates
5. Agenda
6. Bad timing for tenders as oil rates decline
Today
This Week
1. Samaras summons bond vigilantes with euro exit talk
2. A friendly yet firm message from Pierre Moscovici
3. Europe's drama in Greece needs final act to avoid tragedy
4. High stakes
5. On the edge but not gutless
6. Girl, aged 11, gives birth on Crete
   Find us ...
  ... on
Twitter
     ... on Facebook   
About us  |  Subscriptions  |  Advertising  |  Contact us  |  Athens Plus  |  RSS  |   
Copyright © 2014, H KAΘHMEPINH All Rights Reserved.