Friday April 25, 2014 Search
Weather | Athens
21o C
15o C
News
Business
Comment
Life
Sports
Community
Survival Guide
Greek Edition
Europe's half-hearted bid to protect its banks

European Central Bank (ECB) President Mario Draghi (l) speaks with Dutch Finance Minister and Eurogroup President Jeroen Dijsselbloem before a Eurogroup Council meeting at EU Headquarters in Brussels on December 17.

By John O'Donnell

Europe's efforts to form a united front behind euro zone banks are reaching a climax, but many fear they will fail to restore confidence and prove flimsy should another crisis strike.

After more than a year of talks, ministers from across the European Union agreed early on Thursday a scheme to close failing banks, but the process will be complex and politicized. They also stopped short of an ambitious plan for euro zone countries to help each other in tackling problem lenders.

An agency and fund to wind down bad banks, working in tandem with the European Central Bank as the new watchdog, is an important step towards banking union, but the loose ends could lead to the complete unraveling of the project.

Although hailed as a "historic" moment by France's Finance Minister Pierre Moscovici, many who emerged from the meeting into the Brussels rain were disappointed by the result.

"It's really a farce," said one senior official involved, who asked not to be named. "We're patting other on the shoulder and congratulating each other, but really what has been achieved is a far cry from what was needed."

After the agreement among countries, talks now begin with the European Parliament to finalize the law.

With no immediate banking crisis in sight, the new structure is likely to go untested for now, but it could buckle if one were to happen.

Furthermore, promises to pool euro zone resources to deal with bad banks are so distant - only after 10 years if at all - that they will do little to shore up confidence.

In the meantime, banks will pay into a fund that will grow to 55 billion euros ($75 billion), but only by around 2026, and that amount would have been entirely eaten up by the Irish banking bailout alone. New rules would, however, push more of the burden onto bank creditors.

Some officials fear missing elements in the scheme could restrain the European Central Bank from revealing the true extent of banks' problems in health checks next year if this would overburden weak countries with a costly bill for their repair.

For Alan Ahearne, an economist who advised the Irish government when it was sunk by its banking collapse in 2010, the deal does not amount to much.

"The sovereign is still the backstop for its own banking system," he said. "That's not a proper banking union. That means that funding costs for banks in peripheral countries remain high and sovereign borrowing costs will remain high."

What has been achieved in Europe is a pale shadow of the United States, where the federal government can transfer funds to help weaker states. Strong countries in the euro zone such as Germany do not send aid to weaker states such as Portugal or Greece. Instead, they lend them money.

"The state of Pennsylvania does not have to issue bank guarantees. That's done by federal agencies," said Ahearne. "That's true banking union."

German deal

Compounding this problem, the procedure that will be used to shut a bank in the euro zone will be heavily politicized, involving as many as all 18 countries in the currency bloc, each fighting to protect its own interests.

This process, described as "laughable" by one economist, will also involve officials from the European Commission as well as a new agency tasked with closing banks. Although ministers agreed a fast-track procedure, even lawyers in the room were perplexed by how it should work.

The European Central Bank, whose representative in the meeting Vitor Constancio was highly critical throughout negotiations, is not satisfied. But there is little the ECB, which wants to stay outside the political wrangle, can do.

Instead, it and others hope the deal can be toughened up in negotiations with the European Parliament.

Sharon Bowles, an influential lawmaker who will play a key role in these negotiations said the system proposed was too political. "We don't trust the countries on this," she said.

But it seems unlikely that they will be able to persuade Germany, which continues to stand firm against the use of euro zone money to back a scheme for tackling troubled banks, to soften its position. Throughout negotiations Berlin has determined much of the agenda.

It succeeded in winning an early introduction of EU rules that allow the imposition of losses from early 2016 on the bondholders and even large depositors of failing banks, as happened in Cyprus.

Yet the quid pro quo that many of its peers expected, namely that Germany would sanction pan-euro-zone backing for a fund to cover the clean-up costs, never materialized.

"It's a very German deal," said one official, who attended the negotiations. "There is not much there for the others."

Germany's finance minister trumpeted the agreement as a route to impose losses on investors.

One ally, Dutch Finance Minister Jeroen Dijsselbloem, was even more forthright. "Everyone is always very interested in the backstop. I'm interested in pre-stops," he said.

"Banks ... can take the first blow. The second blow will have to be carried by the investors, shareholders, bondholders in the banks. And the third blow ... will be carried by the fund, but the fund is also paid by the sector itself."

But Sven Giegold, a German member of the European Parliament, said Germany's dismantling of much of the deal may come back to haunt it. "I find it shocking that one country is able to push through so much," he said. "When one country has too much power, this can backfire." [Reuters]

ekathimerini.com , Friday December 20, 2013 (10:15)  
Ellaktor lands major Doha metro project
World seeks produce from Greece
Eurobank opens book for capital increase
Govt presents its growth model for the coming years
Work at new Athens cultural center gathering pace
It was revealed on Thursday that the outer shell of buildings at the Stavros Niarchos Foundation Cultural Center should be completed by July 28. The planting of trees and shrubs on the 17-he...
Greece makes request for debt relief as loan tranche approved
Greece made its first official request on Thursday for further debt relief as the Euro Working Group (EWG) met in Brussels to rubber-stamp the 2013 primary surplus and approve the release of...
Inside News
SOCCER
4,000 officers to police Greek Cup final
Police says it will ban mass gatherings in central Athens amid heavy security measures planned for Saturday's Greek Cup final between Panathinaikos and PAOK at the Olympic Stadium. More than...
BASKETBALL
Never underestimate the Greek hoopsters
Olympiakos and Panathinaikos, who between them have won the last three European crowns, won again at home on Wednesday to take their Euroleague play-off series with Real Madrid and CSKA Mosc...
Inside Sports
COMMENTARY
At the mercy of fools
The death of a young man at an Easter lunch in a village near Rethymno on Crete and the very serious injury of an American guest at a Resurrection ceremony on Santorini must not be forgotten...
COMMENTARY
Putting the party above the country
The case of Sabiha Suleiman, the Roma activist whose candidacy for the European Parliament was announced by SYRIZA only to be withdrawn shortly afterward, is an illustration of the leftist o...
Inside Comment
SPONSORED LINK: FinanzNachrichten.de
SPONSORED LINK: BestPrice.gr
RECENT NEWS
1. Ellaktor lands major Doha metro project
2. World seeks produce from Greece
3. Eurobank opens book for capital increase
4. Govt presents its growth model for the coming years
5. Work at new Athens cultural center gathering pace
6. Greece makes request for debt relief as loan tranche approved
more news
Today
This Week
1. Ellaktor lands major Doha metro project
2. Putting the party above the country
3. Three missing from cargo ship that went down off Crete
4. Central Athens cleanup a sign of Greece's turnaround
5. Strong card in debt talks
6. Samaras meeting with Dimon key to Greek return to bond markets
Today
This Week
1. Greece startup leaders say they cant break jobless cycle alone
2. Ground-breaking Good Friday mass signals thaw in Cyprus
3. Mayoral candidates clash over Athens mosque plans
4. Putting the party above the country
5. Government looks to kick on
6. Greece offers to help find Turkish F-16 lost in 1996
Find us ...
... on
Twitter
... on Facebook
About us  |  Subscriptions  |  Advertising  |  Contact us  |  Athens Plus  |  RSS  |   
Copyright 2014, H KAΘHMEPINH All Rights Reserved.