Saturday November 22, 2014 Search
Weather | Athens
18o C
10o C
News
Business
Comment
Life
Sports
Community
Survival Guide
Greek Edition
Musical chairs at ECB leaves Germany on guard for doves’ attack

By Simon Kennedy

When the European Central Bank policy makers first convened in June 1998, Bundesbank President Hans Tietmeyer didn’t like what he saw.

The sign in the front of every seat shouldn’t carry the name of each nation’s central bank, but that of the ECB, he said. That would underscore how officials set monetary policy for the whole euro area and not represent their homelands.

From this January there may be a need to highlight who comes from where. That’s because with last week’s acceptance of Lithuania as the currency bloc’s 19th member, a new voting mechanism comes into action.

While President Mario Draghi and his five colleagues on the Frankfurt-based Executive Board will continue to have a vote on policy each time the Governing Council gathers, rules first set in 2003 and revised in 2008 dictate that others will have less of a formal say. At present each national central bank has a vote every month.

The five biggest economies -- Germany, France, Spain, Italy and the Netherlands -- will rotate so each sits out one vote in five. The 14 smaller countries will share 11 votes on a rotating basis. The system will be revised again when the euro’s membership reaches 22.

‘Secure Position’

“This means that the biggest five can consider themselves in a rather secure position, whereas small countries are likely to see their influence decrease over time,” Silvia Merler, an affiliate fellow at Bruegel, a Brussels-based research organization, wrote in a blog last week.

Merler estimates the Executive Board will now enjoy 29 percent of the votes at each session, the five biggest will hold 19 percent versus 20 percent today and the smaller countries will have their share reduced to 52 percent from 56 percent. Additionally, as of January the Governing Council will set monetary policy every six weeks rather than monthly.

Theoretically, this may all mean very little for policy. Non-voting governors will still participate in the debate and shape any vote that way. Also the ECB makes most policy decisions on the basis of consensus rather than votes anyway.

Presentationally, there may be more of a challenge because of disquiet in Germany even though Chancellor Angela Merkel’s government isn’t seeking a permanent vote for the Bundesbank akin to that enjoyed at the Federal Reserve’s Open Market Committee by the Fed Bank of New York.

Not Popular

The ECB’s crisis-fighting measures of late haven’t proved popular in the euro area’s largest economy with Axel Weber resigning as Bundesbank president in 2011 and his successor Jens Weidmann opposing Draghi’s bond-buying plan of 2012 and last November’s interest rate cut.

Draghi’s still-untapped program was challenged in Germany’s Federal Constitutional Court and only this month a business group allied with Merkel’s party balked at giving him an award after concluding it was too soon to praise him for stemming the euro area’s debt crisis.

The German suspicion, already fanned by local media, may be that more dovish members of the ECB council use the months Germany lacks a vote to push through the easier monetary policy the German population already has qualms about.

The view of economists is that would be foolhardy given it would likely harm the ECB’s legitimacy in Germany, something the central bank can ill afford. Any push could also draw the objection of board member Sabine Lautenschlaeger, a former Bundesbanker.

The upshot is even with the musical chairs any major policy choice will likely only be made in the months the Bundesbank carries a vote.

“It seems unlikely that decisions will be taken ‘behind the back’ of any big country,” said Merler.

[Bloonberg]

ekathimerini.com , Monday Jul 28, 2014 (15:19)  
More cash for banks with same papers
Growth to fuel rise in revenues
Commercial property draws interest from investors
Sony chooses Piraeus as its entry point to Europe
Image of artwork showing humans in blender taken out of schoolbooks
A photograph of a controversial work by a Japanese artist showing people in a blender will be removed from a primary school physics textbook, the Education Ministry said on Friday. The paint...
Simitis supports Venizelos over new movement
Former Prime Minister Costas Simitis on Friday backed PASOK leader Evangelos Venizelos’s proposal to create a new center-left party with the Socialists at its heart. The two men met a day af...
Inside News
INTERVIEW
Tokyo hopes to change the world
The 2020 Summer Olympic and Paralympic Games in Tokyo will serve as a springboard for the rebuilding of Japan’s image and economy following the triple blow of the earthquake, tsunami and nuc...
BASKETBALL
Big win for Greens, tight one for Reds
Panathinaikos scored a crucial as well as emphatic away win at Turow on Thursday that should see it qualify from its tough group to the top 16 of the Euroleague, while Olympiakos saw off vis...
Inside Sports
COMMENTARY
Give Greece a chance
Greece's creditors are testing the country's endurance - again. If they keep pressing, they could split the euro area apart, which would be a disaster for them as much as for Greece. They ne...
COMMENTARY
‘Who lost Greece?’
If, by unhappy chance, Greece’s efforts to create a more efficient economy and more just society should fail, if it turns out that all our sacrifices were in vain, who will be to blame? The ...
Inside Comment
SPONSORED LINK: FinanzNachrichten.de
SPONSORED LINK: BestPrice.gr
 RECENT NEWS
1. Image of artwork showing humans in blender taken out of schoolbooks
2. More cash for banks with same papers
3. Simitis supports Venizelos over new movement
4. Growth to fuel rise in revenues
5. Commercial property draws interest from investors
6. Sony chooses Piraeus as its entry point to Europe
more news
Today
This Week
1. Give Greece a chance
2. Cosco’s Greek unit adds multinational rail-freight client
3. No breakthrough after marathon conference call
4. Israel backs East Med pipeline project
5. Education Ministry mulls over introducing Albanian language classes
6. Greece says EU/IMF lenders disagree with 2015 budget deficit estimate
Today
This Week
1. Double quake on Atalanti fault line rattles Greek capital [Update]
2. Greece and Poland switch roles as young Greeks head to vibrant Eastern European country for better prospects
3. Constructively disrupting the Greek start-up ecosystem: What will the impact be?
4. Anti-junta uprising anniversary to be marked amid tight security
5. Biden heads to Istanbul amid tension over Cyprus EEZ violation
6. Carlsberg takes control of Greek brewer Olympic Brewery [Update]
   Find us ...
  ... on
Twitter
     ... on Facebook   
About us  |  Subscriptions  |  Advertising  |  Contact us  |  Athens Plus  |  RSS  |   
Copyright © 2014, H KAΘHMEPINH All Rights Reserved.