Wednesday May 27, 2015 Search
Weather | Athens
14o C
09o C
News
Business
Comment
Life
Sports
Community
Survival Guide
Greek Edition
Cyprus’s Groundhog Day

A United Nations soldier stands guard as Greek Cypriot President Anastasiades meets with Turkish Cypriot leader Dervis Eroglu at the now defunct Nicosia international airport in the United Nations Buffer Zone that separates the internationally recognized southern part of the island from the Turkish-occupied north of Cyprus on February 11.

By Nikos Skoutaris *

In the classic 90s comedy “Groundhog Day,” an arrogant and egocentric Bill Murray finds himself in a time loop repeating the same day again and again. Every time the negotiations for a settlement of the Cyprus issue are resumed, each and every student of the protracted conflict feels a bit like Bill Murray.

That is not just because the negotiations have been resumed endless times (at least three in the last 10 years) but also because their evolution follows the same pattern. There is optimism in the beginning, frustration as time passes by and sheer disappointment at the end. So the main question is whether the present negotiations can break the time loop and move us to the day after Groundhog Day, which will entail the reunification of the island.

I believe that potentially they could, as long as both communities manage their expectations as to what the negotiations may produce. According to the joint declaration that Cyprus President Nicos Anastasiades and Turkish-Cypriot leader Dervis Eroglu released, “the settlement will be based on a bicommunal, bizonal federation with political equality.” To make a (very) long story short, this means that both communities will be participating effectively in all organs and decisions of the federal government of the reunified Cyprus. This will most probably happen through a numerical formula. For example, 7:3 was the formula in the Zurich Agreement for the government and the legislature of the Cyprus Republic while in the Annan Plan it was 2:1 and 3:1 for the government and the lower house of the Parliament respectively.

More importantly, bizonality means that there will be two constituent states – one Greek-Cypriot and one Turkish-Cypriot. And each constituent state will be administered by the respective community which “would be guaranteed a clear majority of the population and of land ownership in the area” (Report of the UN Secretary-General S/1990/21183). Given that more than 75 percent of the privately owned land in northern Cyprus belong to Greek Cypriots, it is unavoidable that the owners of property affected by the current status quo would not enjoy an absolute right to reinstatement. Thus, the future restitution scheme will combine reinstatement for some dispossessed owners, exchange and/or compensation for some others. And even those whose property rights will be reinstated might be living under Turkish-Cypriot administration.

Does this arrangement ring a bell? Of course it does. It sounds suspiciously similar to the “evil” Annan Plan and every other plan that has been proposed over the last 30 years. But this is not a result of a world conspiracy against Cypriot Hellenism, it is rather the by-product of the agreed basic parameters of bizonality, bicommunality and political equality. Those parameters were agreed in the 70s by the leaders of the two communities and they have never been reversed. Instead they have been verified, developed and incorporated in the UN settlement proposals. Most importantly, they have been accepted by all the leaders of the two communities, including the late Cyprus President Tassos Papadopoulos (July 8, 2006 Agreement).

In the movie, the time loop only breaks when Murray manages to befriend almost everyone in the city during the day. Somehow likewise, the time loop of the Cyprus issue will break only once the two communities are prepared to realize and accept that if the reunification is to take place, it will only take place under the framework they set almost four decades ago. Having lived apart for five decades, it is almost a mission impossible. But, as is often said, you don’t make peace with your friends but with your enemies.

* Dr Nikos Skoutaris is a lecturer of EU law in the UEA Law School and visiting senior fellow at the European Institute, LSE. He is the author of “The Cyprus Issue: The Four Freedoms in a Member State Under Siege.”

ekathimerini.com , Wednesday February 12, 2014 (16:53)  
Romantic notions meet reality
Solving the Gordian Knot
Shame, justice, democracy
Worrying signs in ruling party
Commissioner Avramopoulos calls for EU solidarity on immigration issue [Update]
The European Commission proposed easing the impact of the Mediterranean migration crisis on Italy and Greece by moving 40,000 refugees to countries further north. The proposal looked set to ...
Ahead of G7, US warns Europe not to miscalculate over Greece [Update]
The United States urged European negotiators not to miscalculate as they try to negotiate a debt deal with Greece's cash-strapped government, because the cost of a Greek exit from the euro z...
Inside News
Economic sentiment weakens in Cyprus in May, says survey
Economic sentiment in Cyprus weakened in May, a publicly funded survey said on Wednesday, as businesses forecast a worsening financial situation in the coming three months. The Economic Sent...
ECB said to leave emergency aid level for Greek banks unchanged
The European Central Bank left the level of emergency cash available to Greek banks unchanged from a week ago, said two people familiar with the matter. During a telephone call on Wednesday,...
Inside Business
SOCCER
AEK Athens returns to top league after financial collapse
Greek club AEK Athens has just returned to the country's top soccer league, two years after financial collapse sent it to a lower league. One of the country's largest clubs, AEK sealed its s...
SOCCER
Berg brace gives Panathinaikos four-point lead
Panathinaikos beat Atromitos on Sunday and took advantage of the goalless draw between PAOK and Asteras Tripolis to open a four-point gap from PAOK at the top of the Super League play-off mi...
Inside Sports
SPONSORED LINK: FinanzNachrichten.de
SPONSORED LINK: BestPrice.gr
 RECENT NEWS
1. Commissioner Avramopoulos calls for EU solidarity on immigration issue [Update]
2. Economic sentiment weakens in Cyprus in May, says survey
3. Ahead of G7, US warns Europe not to miscalculate over Greece [Update]
4. EU says fiscal targets, pensions, labor still to be agreed with Greece
5. Schaeuble says up to Greece to decide on capital controls
6. Vouliagmeni lifeguard taken into custody on child pornography charges
more news
Today
This Week
1. Some 300 mln left banks on Tuesday
2. Romantic notions meet reality
3. Target of Greek scorn shapes nation’s fate as IMF’s storm-chaser
4. The G-7's problem: Can the world deal with a Greek default?
5. Solving the Gordian Knot
6. FYROM PM blames Greece for name impasse
Today
This Week
1. Conspiracy madness
2. National self-awareness put to the test
3. Albanian demarche raises concerns about possible territorial claims over Greece
4. Hotel contracts with a ‘Greek default clause’
5. Neither Grexit nor a dual currency will solve Greece’s problems
6. Merkel said to plan address for Greece if deal reached
   Find us ...
  ... on
Twitter
     ... on Facebook   
About us  |  Subscriptions  |  Advertising  |  Contact us  |  Athens Plus  |  RSS  |   
Copyright © 2015, H KAΘHMEPINH All Rights Reserved.