Sunday August 31, 2014 Search
Weather | Athens
31o C
24o C
News
Business
Comment
Life
Sports
Community
Survival Guide
Greek Edition
Troika made mistakes but was necessary for Greece, says MEP heading inquiry

By Tom Ellis

Mistakes have been made but the troika was necessary and it managed to prevent the bankruptcy of a number of European countries, Ottmar Karas, a European Parliament vice president and one of the MEPs leading an inquiry into the troika, tells Kathimerini.

We had to repair the boat during the storm. The storm is not yet over. But we have saved the boat that is what everybody has to acknowledge, says the Austrian politician, who is in Athens with his colleagues this week on a fact-finding mission. He adds that the lack of the necessary mechanism in the European Union meant that the involvement of the International Monetary Fund, and its expertise, in the bailouts was unavoidable.

Karas is due to meet members of the Greek government, including Finance Minister Yannis Stournaras, as well as representatives of labor unions and business groups.

What is your assessment of how the troika has functioned so far?

The troika has been an interim solution. It was necessary to have an instrument like the troika. It prevented the bankruptcy of several countries. Without it, the situation today would be much worse. But this does not mean that every single decision and the decision procedures have been perfect. The current crisis in Europe has been the biggest crisis since World War II. Nobody, no country, no institution was prepared for such a situation. We had to repair the boat during the storm. The storm is not yet over. But we have saved the boat that is what everybody has to acknowledge. But now we have to ask what can be done in a better way in similar situations in the future.

As the first country where the troika implemented a program, some say that Greece was the victim of experimentation and too many mistakes.

Our meetings in Athens on Wednesday and Thursday will also help to look into this question. Most countries in Europe have internal instruments for a situation when a local government is threatened by insolvency. In my home country, in such a case, the regional governor sends a state commissioner to the ailing town and the commissioner takes over the bookkeeping. Every state in Europe has such mechanisms. On an EU level, we do not have such an instrument yet. The troika was the stopgap. And, of course I use the same picture again if you repair the boat during the storm at sea, it is clear that everybody gets a good shaking. Of course such a ride is bumpy. The storm showed in which areas the EU was not capable of acting properly. That is why we must learn now from this experience to be better prepared in the future.

Should and will there be accountability for the troika's actions?

I want solidarity within the EU. But we need instruments to organize the solidarity in a better way. The instruments of solidarity need transparency and democratic legitimacy and parliamentarian scrutiny. If the community helps an ailing member, those who help must be sure that their help is used properly and those who receive help have the right to be better informed. Only if the process is transparent, only if the parliaments are involved, will both sides those who help and those who receive help agree to make considerable efforts.

Should the programs be the result of solely technocratic analyses or should they take into account the social reality and political repercussions?

Any sound political decision needs these two eyes. You cannot do politics if you are not based on an accurate analysis of the facts. Anything else is wool-gathering. But you also cannot do politics if you do not pick people up where they are. If people do not understand what you do, they do not follow you. That is why parliaments have been invented: to create a space for public debate and to build a consensus, maybe not of everybody, but of a majority. That is why I want parliaments involved in the troika's decisions.

The IMF has accepted making a mistake with the multipliers. Were the measures proposed and implemented in Greece the correct ones?

The focus of the European Parliament is not to judge this or that particular measure in the past, but to propose options how to organize the troika better in the future. And again, repairing a boat in the storm is a shaky endeavor. That is why we have to learn the right lesson now.

Were you satisfied with the answers given by European Commission Vice President Olli Rehn, former European Central Bank President Jean-Claude Trichet and EU bailout fund chief Klaus Regling during your recent hearings in Strasbourg?

Our evaluation of the work of the troika is trying to take many different aspects into account. The hearings with Mr Rehn, Mr Trichet, Mr Regling and others, but also the missions on the ground in Portugal, Cyprus, Ireland and now in Greece are important to get a full picture. I am thankful to everybody who collaborated with Parliament's evaluation work. But I do not want and cannot anticipate the final result of our evaluation report, which will be voted by the European Parliament, probably in March.

Should the IMF have been invited to participate in programs for European countries?

The help of the IMF was indispensable. At the beginning of the crisis, the EU did not have the expertise the IMF had. The IMF has organized help programs for ailing states for many decades now. Since every single EU member state is a member of the IMF, we also had the legal right to call for the IMF's help. But it is also true that the share of IMF money in the programs decreased from a third at the beginning to less than 10 percent now.
We are now discussing three different options for how the work of the troika could be organized differently in the future: The IMF does it all alone, or the European Commission which has acquired the necessary expertise by now takes over and does it all alone, or the European Stability Mechanism ESM evolves into an European Monetary Fund. My personal preference is the third option, but we need further discussions in the Parliament.

ekathimerini.com , Tuesday Jan 28, 2014 (22:23)  
Keeping an eye on international developments
A few good men
Greek quest for debt relief faces hurdles in Paris
Stifled dreams
Traveling on public transport in Athens gets cheaper
Commuters will pay 20 cents less for tickets allowing them to use all modes of public transportation in Athens as of Monday, though they will be valid for 70 minutes rather than 90 as was th...
Push made for cuts in education as merger scheme fails
Finance Ministry officials are pressing the Education Ministry to cut costs after it emerged that a program for merging university and technical college departments failed to save 68 million...
Inside News
Disappearing inflation heightens Draghi concerns
Eurozone inflation dropped to a fresh five-year low in August, data showed on Friday, something likely to concern the European Central Bank but not force it into immediate policy action. Con...
Ministry launches work experience program for unemployed graduates
The Labor, Social Security and Welfare Ministry is preparing to launch a work experience program for unemployed youths aged between 18 and 24, through private sector jobs, as part of a new a...
Inside Business
SOCCER
Tough draw for Greek sides in Europe League Greek stage
Following Thursday nights high, when all three Greek teams competing in the Europa League made it into the group stage of the competition, a harsh reality struck Friday as they found out wh...
JUDO
Greek judoka Iliadis triples up as Aguiar stuns Tcheumeo
Greek star Ilias Iliadis claimed his third world title in the under-90kg category in Chelyabinsk on Friday as Brazilian Mayra Aguiar and Colombian Yuri Alvear won gold in the womens under-7...
Inside Sports
SPONSORED LINK: FinanzNachrichten.de
SPONSORED LINK: BestPrice.gr
RECENT NEWS
1. Traveling on public transport in Athens gets cheaper
2. Push made for cuts in education as merger scheme fails
3. Govt aims to curb measures, secure loans, allow tax relief
4. DIMAR chief Kouvelis hints about presidency
5. French expert says Crete crocodile in good health, aged 4-7
6. Tensions mar regional ity swearing-in ceremony
more news
Today
This Week
1. Keeping an eye on international developments
2. A few good men
3. Disappearing inflation heightens Draghi concerns
4. Two men drown off Crete coast in strong tides
5. Traveling on public transport in Athens gets cheaper
6. Push made for cuts in education as merger scheme fails
Today
This Week
1. Attack on gay couple in Athens leaves one man needing surgery
2. Purification rituals
3. The battle against progress
4. Thessaloniki mayor Boutaris sworn in wearing yellow star amid Golden Dawn protests
5. Strong undersea quake occurs off island of Milos, felt in Athens
6. Athens finalizes Paris talks goals
Find us ...
... on
Twitter
... on Facebook
About us  |  Subscriptions  |  Advertising  |  Contact us  |  Athens Plus  |  RSS  |   
Copyright 2014, H KAΘHMEPINH All Rights Reserved.