Tuesday September 2, 2014 Search
Weather | Athens
29o C
23o C
News
Business
Comment
Life
Sports
Community
Survival Guide
Greek Edition
A cheap moratorium on the stigma of eurozone debt

By Thomas Colignatus*

The EU is in a pressure cooker with interest rates that suffer from stigma, i.e. irrational fears of default that become rational and self-fulfilling because higher rates of interest imply a reward. A moratorium is one way to ease the pressure, by temporarily allowing eurozone bonds for 3 percent of GDP per annum to cover deficits. This would buy time to think through a structural solution, as a dash for a fiscal and political federation may be ill-advised given the risk of resentment.

Decision-making in the EU is currently taking place in a pressure-cooker environment, creating the risk of wrong decisions that would only make the situation worse. In the past five years, EU leaders have wandered from one crisis to the other -- created in part by themselves. Now, for example, they recognize that the «voluntary default» on Greek debt was not so wise. Last week, German Chancellor Angela Merkel expressed her preference for a fiscal and political federation, though that carries risks too. The transfer of national sovereignty taking place under the current conditions of austerity and depression in southern Europe, could render the European project a diktat disliked by Europeans instead of a community that everyone welcomes. Historically Europe’s greatest danger is resentment, and such a federation may not be what is needed just now.

Current high rates of interest derive from the stigma and the key problem in the eurozone is that there is no structural mechanism yet to eliminate it and problems with interest rates are too weak an argument for a political federation.

There is a straightforward way to buy precious time to discuss structural reform with some ease: allow eurozone members to borrow 3% of GDP per annum, for the next 10 years, with full backing by the ECB. Since old debt is already in the hands of market counterparts it is not really as relevant, and only new deficits are important for the annual budgets of the member states. With the backing of the ECB the rates of interest in the eurozone could drop to an acceptable low level. Italy, Spain, Portugal and Ireland would be immediately saved and we would get a clearer picture of what can be done about Greece. After those 10 years only 30% of their GDP will be have such backing by the ECB, so that coverage would be limited and the «no bailout» condition still satisfied.

This moratorium would use euro bonds. Proponents of euro bonds generally want them structurally and not just for a moratorium. Earlier I advised against such bonds since they destroy important market information. For the purposes of this moratorium they could, however, form an instrument that everyone understands and that is immediately effective. My own structural analysis leads to the suggestion of a regime ladder, with different stages depending upon the distance from the target of 60% of debt to GDP. However, my structural analysis is only one of the many approaches. The idea of the moratorium is to create more time to evaluate all of them, also using what we have learned about how a crisis can evolve.

There is a moral hazard that some member states would take advantage of such a moratorium and not participate in the creation of a structural solution. It is more likely, however, that the whole of Europe has become more aware of the need for a structural solution. Nevertheless it would be possible to define phases, say one year for job-creation and agenda-setting, and subsequently three periods of three years for other aspects to be developed in full -- say on investments, banks, governance -- and a unanimous decision to be reached on whether there is sufficient progress to continue with the moratorium.

This proposed moratorium would come at a cost for Germany and Holland, as their interest rates are exceptionally low because of fears about southern Europe. Europe as a whole could ask Germany and Holland to accept normal rates of interest again to create this moratorium. Given Chancellor Merkel’s objectives and given that the «no bailout» clause is satisfied, it would be a wise decision and the best news that Europeans have heard since all this started in August 2007.

----------

* Thomas Colignatus is a Dutch econometrician.

ekathimerini.com , Tuesday Jan 31, 2012 (20:08)  
EU’s three big problems all linked
A great president
Don’t feed the zombies
Keeping an eye on international developments
Education minister calls for probe into predecessor´s reform plan
Following reports that a plan to reform the tertiary education sector launched in the spring of 2013 failed to lead to millions of euros in savings, Education Minister Andreas Loverdos on Mo...
Anti-racism bill goes back to Parliament
An anti-racism bill, foreseeing stiffer penalties for individuals and political parties that engage in racism or incite racist violence, is to be debated in Parliament on Tuesday following m...
Inside News
Tourism targets rise ever higher
The latest data have allowed the Hellenic Association of Tourism Enterprises (SETE) to raise its target for tourism arrivals and revenues this year higher still. During a meeting with main o...
Horse race betting hurdle removed for OPAP
The new tender for the concession of the right to organize and operate wagering on horse races in Greece for the next 20 years will include a number of changes in its terms, despite assuranc...
Inside Business
BASKETBALL
Greek hoopsters go top of their group in World Cup
Greece has qualified to the second round of the FIBA World Cup after going top of its group of six through a third win in as many group games in Spain. On Monday it beat Puerto Rico 90-79 in...
SOCCER
Fulham striker Mitroglou set to re-join Olympiakos
Greek champions Olympiakos Piraeus are set to re-sign Kostas Mitroglou on loan from English second tier club Fulham after the striker arrived in Athens for talks on Sunday. An Olympiakos spo...
Inside Sports
SPONSORED LINK: FinanzNachrichten.de
SPONSORED LINK: BestPrice.gr
 RECENT NEWS
1. Greek hoopsters go top of their group in World Cup
2. Tourism targets rise ever higher
3. Horse race betting hurdle removed for OPAP
4. Revised GDP data confirm that Greek growth is near
5. Measures to reduce unemployment
6. Peachy export data despite Russian embargo
more news
Today
This Week
1. Excavation work at Amphipolis reveals section of marble mosaic floor
2. A great president
3. Erdogan visits Turkish-occupied Cyprus
4. Greek economy shrinks at slowest pace since late 2008
5. Don’t feed the zombies
6. Greek officials meet to fine tune strategy for Paris talks with troika
Today
This Week
1. Attack on gay couple in Athens leaves one man needing surgery
2. The battle against progress
3. Thessaloniki mayor Boutaris sworn in wearing yellow star amid Golden Dawn protests
4. Strong undersea quake occurs off island of Milos, felt in Athens
5. Greek quest for debt relief faces hurdles in Paris
6. Hardouvelis, ECB executive discuss bank program, stress tests
   Find us ...
  ... on
Twitter
     ... on Facebook   
About us  |  Subscriptions  |  Advertising  |  Contact us  |  Athens Plus  |  RSS  |   
Copyright © 2014, H KAΘHMEPINH All Rights Reserved.