Thursday March 5, 2015 Search
Weather | Athens
20o C
11o C
News
Business
Comment
Life
Sports
Community
Survival Guide
Greek Edition
The placebo effect and the economy

By Nikos Konstandaras

Among the greatest mistakes made in the years of Greece’s hard landing is that citizens did not get the chance to sense that aside from austerity and pain the economic adjustment program also brought some benefits. The many sacrifices and injustices could have been softened to some extent by the targeted improvement of state and social services which became ever more necessary as the economy worsened. Instead of reforms being seen as something good that would offset some of the difficulties that citizens faced, they were presented as further punishment.

The governments of the past four years were incapable of arguing that there was anything positive in the reform package, while the other parties were free to present every change as a catastrophe, thus contributing to a climate of uncertainty and pessimism. Our partners added to this with statements and actions that left open the possibility of Greece finding itself exiled from the common European currency. As was to be expected, this discouraged investments by Greeks and foreigners and caused a drop in consumption, leading to even worse consequences for the economy and society. Austerity on its own caused serious damage, which is measured in terms of lost revenues and high unemployment; pessimism worsened the negative effects of the crisis by reducing the flow of money even further and by encouraging opposition to every reform.

In the past few days we have witnessed an effort to change the climate, to make it appear the crisis has ended and that Greece is making a leap toward normality. The primary surplus and the five-year bond sold to international investors raise the hope that our creditors’ harsh grip will loosen, money will flow into the real economy and the country will recover. These developments, along with words of encouragement from foreign officials and some publications, play a positive role in improving the climate. It is the light at the end of the tunnel for which we have yearned – and sometimes even the illusion of light leads us toward it.

It is acknowledged in medical research that a pharmaceutically inactive substance can have a positive effect when it raises hope in the patient’s heart. Perhaps the single most effective use of this “placebo effect” on the European debt crisis was European Central Bank Governor Mario Draghi’s vague declaration that the bank would do “whatever it takes” to support heavily indebted eurozone members. Without saying anything specific that would overstep his mandate, he calmed the markets and allowed troubled countries, like Italy, to keep borrowing.

Studies into the Greek crisis and the adjustment program will have to look carefully at the consequences of the opposite of the placebo effect – when a nation drinks the poison of punishment, alienation and pessimism. To reach the end of the crisis and to avoid greater pessimism, however, vague hope is not enough. We have to see real economic growth, improvements in our daily lives, good state services and reliable public transportation. And we must feel that justice will prevail.

ekathimerini.com , Thursday April 17, 2014 (18:32)  
Greek officials have ruffled feathers in Brussels for not having good diplomatic manners
Up the creek without a paddle
Populism backfires
Greece and the four month window of opportunity
Police, ministry dodge blame for migrants order
The Greek Police and the Interior Ministry on Wednesday both dodged the blame after new police guidelines on migration control were issued and then revoked within a few hours following a veh...
Speaker says laws may not stand
Parliament Speaker Zoe Constantopoulou suggested on Wednesday that some laws voted by less than 151 of 300 MPs when Golden Dawn MPs being held in pretrial custody were not allowed to cast ba...
Inside News
Industrial products offset agricultural exports’ losses
The decline in the export of agricultural products and losses resulting from the Russian embargo were offset last year by the increase in exports of industrial products and Greek products’ i...
BoC disposing of 41 properties across Greece
The Bank of Cyprus group is putting up for sale a total of 41 properties across Greece which in most cases are leased out to third parties and belong to the group’s subsidiary firm, Cyprus L...
Inside Business
SOCCER
Super League restarts, but behind closed doors
Deputy Minister for Sports Stavros Kontonis announced on Wednesday the resumption of the Super League this weekend after it was suspended last week following crowd trouble at the Athens derb...
SOCCER
Marinakis fines Olympiakos players
Olympiakos president Evangelos Marinakis on Monday fined the team 500,000 euros for disappointing performances and called on them to make a «sacrifice» to win trophies or leave. "Olympiakos ...
Inside Sports
SPONSORED LINK: FinanzNachrichten.de
SPONSORED LINK: BestPrice.gr
 RECENT NEWS
1. Industrial products offset agricultural exports’ losses
2. BoC disposing of 41 properties across Greece
3. RAE offers gift to natural gas power plants
4. Emergency intervention by BoG to acquire T-bills
5. Valavani offers debt penalty write-off
6. Police, ministry dodge blame for migrants order
more news
Today
This Week
1. Up the creek without a paddle
2. Greek officials have ruffled feathers in Brussels for not having good diplomatic manners
3. Panousis says no official decision on undocumented migrants
4. More Germans booking holidays in Greece, tourism chief says
5. For Greece, a lesson from Ireland, Kenny says
6. ECB glimpse of Cyprus debt shows limits of bank cleanup
Today
This Week
1. Greece to make international protest over Turkey reserving Aegean air space
2. A fierce battle looms
3. SYRIZA feeling the pain
4. The Greek tax drama
5. The unlikely winners of Greece's surrender on euro
6. Tsipras reversal draws Greek sympathy as party rumblings rise
   Find us ...
  ... on
Twitter
     ... on Facebook   
About us  |  Subscriptions  |  Advertising  |  Contact us  |  Athens Plus  |  RSS  |   
Copyright © 2015, H KAΘHMEPINH All Rights Reserved.